Old Florida Coastal Stays: Casey Key Gulf-Front Motels, Venice Island & Manasota Key
Where to Stay
7 min read

Old Florida Coastal Stays: Casey Key Gulf-Front Motels, Venice Island & Manasota Key

Published 2026-11-02•Sarasota County Field Guide
Quick Summary & Local Overview

Travelers seeking quiet "Old Florida" coastal lodging gravitate to southern Sarasota County: Casey Key and Nokomis offer vintage single-story Gulf-front motels and mainland bay resorts minutes from North Jetty; Venice Island combines walkable historic avenues with beachside inns near the Venice Fishing Pier; and Manasota Key in Englewood provides secluded cottages shaded by sea grapes between Lemon Bay and the Gulf.

Key Field Notes & Takeaways

  • Casey Key & Osprey: Known for mid-century boutique resorts and waterfront mainland retreats near Blackburn Point and Nokomis Beach.
  • Venice Island: One of the few places on Florida’s Gulf Coast where a historic downtown main street (West Venice Avenue) ends directly at a public Gulf beach.
  • Manasota Key (Englewood): Zero high-rises, canopy roads, and direct access to both Lemon Bay boating and Gulf shelling.
  • DBPR licensing: Every public hotel, motel, and vacation rental complex in Sarasota County holds an active Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation lodging license.

Casey Key, Osprey & Nokomis: Vintage Gulf-to-Bay Tranquility

Because Casey Key never permitted high-rise condo development, its southern shoreline near Nokomis Beach retains a rare cluster of mid-century, single-story Gulf-front inns where guests step directly from lawn chairs onto the sand. Just across the Intracoastal Waterway in Osprey and Nokomis, properties such as Casey Key Resorts offer mainland and beachside accommodations within five minutes of Oscar Scherer State Park and the Legacy Trail.

Venice Island & Manasota Key: Walkable Avenues and Sea-Grape Cottages

Further south, Venice Island rewards visitors who enjoy morning walks under banyan and palm trees along the Venetian Waterway Park trail or cycling from West Venice Avenue cafés out to the South Jetty.

In Englewood at the southern edge of Sarasota County, Manasota Key properties sit along a narrow strip of land where sunrise over Lemon Bay and sunset over the Gulf of Mexico are separated by less than 400 yards.

Directory Profiles Mentioned

Explore These Places in The Sarasota Guide

View All Sarasota & Venice Lodging

More in Where to Stay

Back to Where to Stay Hub